So she asks me how I feel about the sloppy retcon Claremont is pulling off over in Excalibur. Specifically, substituting Xorn/Magneto in Morrison's run with an unnamed "imposter".
And, being as I don't really care, I tell her I don't care.
"But it's horrible! It undermines Morrison's entire run on the book. Look at all this stuff on Millarworld"
I agree and then repeat that I really don't care. I add that it's my opinion that 30% of the regular MillarWorld posters are functionally illiterate.
"But it's stupid as fuck, how can you not care?"
It's like this: Yes it is a sloppy retcon. It does remind me of the way Byrne and Claremont sniped each other back when they were feuding. Claremont would write the X-Men vs. Dr. Doom and then a month later Byrne would reveal that the X-Men fought a robot. This went on for some time. This is what happens when you pay fatbears who never stopped being ten-year olds to write for you. However, it's work for hire, I expected this. This is why the only "X" related titles that get my cash are Joss Whedon's Astonishing X-Men and David Hine's District X. And Cable and Deadpool... it's a guilty pleasure, okay? Claremont made "how much Morrison's X-Men suck" the entire point of his run on *choke* "X-Treme X-Men". The fact that he's reversing everything he can get his hands on is not at all surprising. And you know what, I still don't care... it irritates me a little and I figure it's disrespectful and completely kills suspension of disbelief, but *shrug* I'm more than happy to pretend that Claremont isn't writing any X-books while I sit over here and read Seaguy.
Sumbliminal Message: READ SEAGUY!
But otherwise, when I find that I might actually be pissed off or displaying any other weird fanboyish reaction I think back to a story I was once told and suddenly, none of this crap matters...
You see, I have friends in the adult entertainment industry. I see none of you are surprised. Anyway, shortly after the first X-Men film came out, one of my friends in the adult entertainment industry was talking to me about stuff and asking me (since I was a "comic book guy") about X-Men and the like.
So I mention Claremont and she pauses... "Wait, this Chris Claremont guy is the guy who wrote X-Men?"
"Yes."
So then she tells me a story. You see, Claremont hangs around the outskirts of the BDSM scene. Anyone who has read enough of his work probably shouldn't be surprised by this. Anyway, it appears that he once hired a Dominatrix friend of my friend to: a) Dress like Storm and then b) fist him savagely. Apparently, he's had several people do this. My friend never understood the connection and just assumed it was a geek thing. I've had this story indepedently confirmed by one big name comics creator and one comics journalist.
Since that evening, whenever I've been tempted to go on a rant about how Claremont can't write, ect.. I just think of Claremont grunting away at his computer, writing his latest magnum opus, probably involving hot mind control action, fetishwear and lesbian tenticle sex; while a young woman dressed as Storm and making a thousand bucks an hour rams her rubber-gloved hand directly up his ass repeatedly.
Somehow, this usually makes everything better.
And, being as I don't really care, I tell her I don't care.
"But it's horrible! It undermines Morrison's entire run on the book. Look at all this stuff on Millarworld"
I agree and then repeat that I really don't care. I add that it's my opinion that 30% of the regular MillarWorld posters are functionally illiterate.
"But it's stupid as fuck, how can you not care?"
It's like this: Yes it is a sloppy retcon. It does remind me of the way Byrne and Claremont sniped each other back when they were feuding. Claremont would write the X-Men vs. Dr. Doom and then a month later Byrne would reveal that the X-Men fought a robot. This went on for some time. This is what happens when you pay fatbears who never stopped being ten-year olds to write for you. However, it's work for hire, I expected this. This is why the only "X" related titles that get my cash are Joss Whedon's Astonishing X-Men and David Hine's District X. And Cable and Deadpool... it's a guilty pleasure, okay? Claremont made "how much Morrison's X-Men suck" the entire point of his run on *choke* "X-Treme X-Men". The fact that he's reversing everything he can get his hands on is not at all surprising. And you know what, I still don't care... it irritates me a little and I figure it's disrespectful and completely kills suspension of disbelief, but *shrug* I'm more than happy to pretend that Claremont isn't writing any X-books while I sit over here and read Seaguy.
Sumbliminal Message: READ SEAGUY!
But otherwise, when I find that I might actually be pissed off or displaying any other weird fanboyish reaction I think back to a story I was once told and suddenly, none of this crap matters...
You see, I have friends in the adult entertainment industry. I see none of you are surprised. Anyway, shortly after the first X-Men film came out, one of my friends in the adult entertainment industry was talking to me about stuff and asking me (since I was a "comic book guy") about X-Men and the like.
So I mention Claremont and she pauses... "Wait, this Chris Claremont guy is the guy who wrote X-Men?"
"Yes."
So then she tells me a story. You see, Claremont hangs around the outskirts of the BDSM scene. Anyone who has read enough of his work probably shouldn't be surprised by this. Anyway, it appears that he once hired a Dominatrix friend of my friend to: a) Dress like Storm and then b) fist him savagely. Apparently, he's had several people do this. My friend never understood the connection and just assumed it was a geek thing. I've had this story indepedently confirmed by one big name comics creator and one comics journalist.
Since that evening, whenever I've been tempted to go on a rant about how Claremont can't write, ect.. I just think of Claremont grunting away at his computer, writing his latest magnum opus, probably involving hot mind control action, fetishwear and lesbian tenticle sex; while a young woman dressed as Storm and making a thousand bucks an hour rams her rubber-gloved hand directly up his ass repeatedly.
Somehow, this usually makes everything better.

Comments
Ooh, hey, Ultimates...
Where? Unless you're sending this post from the future where John Kerry's president, the US is out of Iraq, and Miller and Hitch finally completed 20 measly pages of material.
You know, when I was a wee lad collecting comics in middle school, I thought Claremont was the greatest comic writer there was. These days, I can barely get through one of his stories. The concepts are great, but dear god that man can't write narratives or dialogue worth shit.
I can't believe he retconned Magneto's death.
No... wait. Yes I can. This is the man who regularly killed characters and brought them back 2 issues later. He made the term "permanent" a complete joke.
At least there's still the Astonishing X-Men... Joss Wheedon is a lifeline.
Marvel is clearly ending their "Dead means dead" policy by bringing back Magneto. Of course, once Excalibur's sales slip and Claremont is off the book, the next writer will come in and retcon all of that, perhaps making this new Magneto an imposter himself. (Remember Joseph?)
Claremont obviously couldn't stand the fact that Morrison junked all the concepts he'd spent years establishing, and people liked the latter's work better. So now that he's gone, everything old is new again.
Except it isn't. I enjoy the books, but to use an example, I have no doubt Cannonball will survive his seemingly life-ending injury at the hands of Claremont's latest invulnerable foe. No shock, no surprise, no lump in throat. Morrison totally shocked me with the Xorn/Magneto revelation, the Jean death, and Wolverine's revenge. Those stories may be trashed now, but they will be renewed as important once the next batch of X-Writers come along.
And I hate the return of the costumes. They're ugly and gaudy, and a hunter/tracker like Wolverine should never, ever, wear bright yellow and blue. I like Bishop's look, but that's because it's reminiscent of his cool XSE outfit.
I wonder if we can replace Claremont's current fister du jour with the chick who's gotten Larry Wachowski tamed. Can you imagine the "Matrix"-style plots Claremont would be writing then? :)
Iceman and Havok fighting over Mary Sue the nurse. Gambit and Rogue relegated to third-stringers. Gambit blinded for no good reason. The return of Xorn, also for no good reason.
As I told Mikey, Austen makes Claremont look like the authors of the Magna Carta. I've been reading the X-Books for 17 years straight, through the horrors of Scott Lobdell and the Seagle/Kelly run, and nothing's made me come this close to ditching them before.
Ironically, "Weapon X", written by a guy I thought was a total hack--Frank Tieri--is actually getting good. It's taking the detritus of Morrison's concepts and using them smartly.
Seriously, can I get a tally on this? It's not like I pay much attention to the All-New, All-Fistable X-Men.
Hey, Kevin, you know any dominatrices who look like Songbird...?
This is why I stopped reading the moment I decided Chuck Austen was pandering to the editors and he was a crap writer.
Marvel has just gone straight back to the early 90s again.
Still, this is also the man who talks excitedly on the X2 DVD about Nightcrawler's two wangs.
(and you want weird - I found my way to this journal entry through the Friends page of a totally-unrelated-to-anything other friend of mine from school. So weird!)
And that's why XTXM was the best X-Book of the last few years.
Mwahahah. ;)
<-Loving Excalibur.
J
On the one hand, some of his scenarios contributed to my own interests (I would pay a FORTUNE for some of the exotic restraint devices I've seen various of his characters in!); on the other hand, I really don't want to imagine Storm fisting anyone... (And also on the other hand, I notice it's always the bad guys doing this stuff. No chance of a side comment about, say, two characters making sure they have the handcuffs on hand, in what's obviously a consensual relationship?)
Interestingly, Morrison played the kink factor much more seriously on his run...
David in DC
PS: Nice interest list, I see... ;)
Hehe.
oh my, this explains everything. i swear, i will never be able to look at a picture of chris claremont again without picturing Storm all lubed up and ready to go. ew.
makes me kinda wonder what's Chuck Austen's secret hang-up to produce something as bad as the two recent Xmen issues (or everything else by him for that matter).
KNIVES.
For LEGS.
Christ.
...
...this is without a doubt the best post of the day thus far.
I now cannot get that image out of my head. I am mentally scarred. But then, I'm accustomed to that.
Also. Yes. Excalibur is sucking. It is sucking quite vigorously. I'm not a fan of Millar, though...
Wow. That Rinella site is really interesting.
All the best
(It makes a difference *grin*)
(linked from the TVTropes "Author Appeal" page)